Friday, September 29, 2023

Tools for measuring Women’s Economic Empowerment (WEE)

Source: Screenshot eNCA Interview with Ms. Tambudzai Ndoro former Acting Director of Programs and Program Manager for Womens Economic and Social Advancement, 27 January 2022.
 

Problem Statement

According to the UN’s Progress on SDG: The Gender Snapshot 2023 report 158 million women and girls globally may be pushed into poverty as a direct result of climate change; food insecurity caused by climate change.  An additional USD$360 billion per year is needed to achieve gender equality and women’s empowerment across the key global goals in 2030.[1] 

Emerging data is showing that insufficient data and evidence to monitor advances and incentivize policy actions are other major impediments to achieving gender equality; as countries lack 44% of the data required to track SDG5.[2]   It is against this backdrop, we ask the question, what are the tools for measuring WEE and how can governments institutionalise compliance in monitoring and evaluation impact of WEE and Gender Equality across sectors including private sector?

What are the tools for measuring WEE?

There are several widely used tools and indicators for measuring women's economic empowerment. Some of the recent and prominent ones include:

 

1.     Africa Gender Development Index (AGDI) - The African Gender Development Index (AGDI) was introduced by the Economic Commission for Africa (ECA) in 2004 to measure gaps between the status of African men and women and assess the progress made by African governments in implementing gender policies.  The AGDI consists of two complementary parts: the Gender Status Index (GSI) and the African Women’s Progress Scoreboard (AWPS). The GSI covers the aspects of gender relations that can be measured quantitatively, while the AWPS captures qualitative issues in relation to the performance of gender policies of African Governments.  The GSI consists of three blocks: the social power, which measures human capabilities; the economic power, which measures economic opportunities; and the political power, which measures voice or political agency. The components and sub-components of the three blocks are measured using 44 indicators, divided into seven components and 11 sub-components.[3] 

 

The AWPS focuses on issues such as women’s rights that cannot be quantified using conventional statistics. It tracks government progress in ratifying regional and international conventions, documents and treaties regarding gender equality and women’s advancement and empowerment, and also in incorporating the principles of these conventions and documents in national laws, programmes and policies.[4] These regional conventions, documents and treaties are: the 1990 African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child; the 2001 NEPAD Framework Document; the 2003 Protocol to the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights on the Rights of Women in Africa; and the 2004 Solemn Declaration on Gender Equality in Africa.[5] The key international instruments included are: CEDAW; the 1989 Convention on the Rights of the Child and its optional protocols adopted in 2000; the ICPD Programme of Action; the Millennium Declaration of 2000, which defined eight Millennium Development Goals; the Beijing Platform for Action; the 1999 optional protocol to CEDAW; and the 2000 Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, especially Women and Children.[6] The AWPS also tracks progress made by countries in implementing three Security Council resolutions on Peace and Security: resolution 1325 of 2000, resolution 1820 of 2008, and resolution 1888 of 2009, and Conventions 100, 111 and 182, adopted by members of the International Labour Organization. The AWPS is composed of four blocks: the three GSI blocks, plus women’s rights.[7]

2.     Extractive Industries and Transparency Initiative (EITI) - The EITI is a global mineral resource governance framework aimed at promoting transparency accountability and good mineral resource governance in resource extracting economies and in the process act as a tool to fight corruption, mismanagement of natural resource wealth, poverty, weak corporate and public governance and opaqueness.[8] Multi-stakeholders groups at national level groups are responsible for implementing EITI at a national level in member countries.

3.     Gender-related Development Index (GDI): The GDI measures gender inequality in three dimensions - health (measured by female and male life expectancy at birth), knowledge (measured by female and male expected years of schooling), and command over economic resources (measured by female and male estimated earned income).  It provides an overall measure of gender disparities in a country.

4.     Gender Inequality Index (GII): The GII measures gender inequalities in reproductive health, empowerment, and economic status. It takes into account maternal mortality rates, adolescent birth rates, educational attainment, representation of women in economic and political decision-making roles, and labour force participation rates.

5.     Women's Economic Empowerment Index (WEEI): The WEEI is a composite index that assesses the economic empowerment of women based on indicators such as labour force participation, educational attainment, representation in decision-making roles, and access to financial resources and assets. It provides a comprehensive measure of women's economic status.

6.     Social Institutions and Gender Index (SIGI): The SIGI measures discrimination against women in social institutions across various dimensions, including family code, physical integrity, civil liberties, access to resources and assets, and ownership rights. It provides insights into the structural barriers that women face in achieving economic empowerment.

7.     Global Gender Gap Index (GGGI): The GGGI measures gender-based gaps in four key areas - economic participation and opportunity, educational attainment, health and survival, and political empowerment. It provides an overall ranking of countries based on gender equality.

 

These tools and indices help track progress in women's economic empowerment and identify areas that require attention and intervention.  However, it is not exhaustive as new tools keep emerging in response to complex dimensions in society.

Friday, September 15, 2023

Seven Key Strategies to Accelerate Women's Economic Empowerment 101

In my previous role when I led a women's economic empowerment programme for an advocacy pan-african institution based in Johannesburg was responsible to identify strategies to advance Women's Economic Empowerment (WEE).  There are several strategies we employed and other partner women's rights, feminists organisations also use.  These strategies are specific to policy, advocacy and communication strategies.  In no particular order of importance or effectiveness here are the seven key strategies:  

  1. Policy Reform: Governments and organizations can work towards implementing policies that promote gender equality and support women's economic empowerment. This may include measures such as legislation to ensure equal pay for equal work, promoting affordable childcare, implementing maternity and paternity leave, and addressing barriers to women's entrepreneurship, among others.  For example, many bilateral and multilateral institutions have integrated a Gender Action Plan and a Gender Policy in line with the Gender national policy. Below are examples of policy mechanisms for WEE and Financial Inclusion Advocacy.  

  2. Advocacy and Awareness: Advocating for women's economic empowerment through campaigns and initiatives can help raise awareness about the importance of gender equality in the workforce. This can be done through partnerships with organizations, engaging stakeholders and decision-makers, and using various communication channels to reach a wide audience.   Organisations such as FEMNET, an African Women Development and Communication Network, have the African Women's Journal where they share impact stories and event highlights; African Women's Development Fund (AWDF) an organisation that amplifies and celebrates African Women's voices and achievementsCGAP is a think tank organisation established FinEquity, a community of practice platform were it brings awareness on the barriers women specifically face in accessing finance; and Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation have The GoalKeeper Report and The Optimist monthly newsletter on LinkedIn, to name a few.  
  3. Capacity Building and Skills Training: Providing women with relevant skills training and access to education can enhance their employability and economic opportunities. This includes supporting vocational training programs, financial literacy initiatives, and entrepreneurship training to empower women to start and grow their own businesses. For example, EMPRETEC is a flagship capacity-building programme of UNCTAD for the promotion of entrepreneurship and micro, small and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs).  I completed an EMPRETEC course in 2012 in Zimbabwe facilitated by the Executive Director of EMPRETEC Zimbabwe Ms. Busi Bango.   Fantastic model anchored on behaviour modification to sustain entrepreneurship habits.
  4. Access to Finance and Resources: Ensuring women have equal access to financial resources and services is crucial. This can be achieved by promoting women's access to loans, grants, and venture capital, as well as providing financial education and support for women-owned businesses.  The Graca Machel Trust, established an Expert Leaders Group (ELG) of women leaders in operating as Deputy Governors or Governors of Central African Banks or Reserve Bank to advocate and mobilise for funding towards women entrepreneurs.
  5. Networking and Mentorship: Facilitating networks and mentorship opportunities for women can provide them with the guidance, support, and connections needed to advance their careers. This can be achieved through mentorship programs, networking events, and online platforms that connect women entrepreneurs with successful professionals.
  6.  Gender-Responsive Investment: Encouraging investors and financial institutions to adopt gender-responsive investment practices can leverage their influence to support women's economic empowerment. This may involve promoting gender lens investing, gender-targeted funds, and engaging with financial institutions to prioritize gender equality in their investment decisions.  Visa Foundation, Mastercard Foundation and MEDA to name a few organizations working actively in this space.  
  7. Monitoring and Evaluation: Implementing robust monitoring and evaluation mechanisms to assess progress and measure the impact of policies and programs is essential. This ensures accountability and helps identify gaps, challenges, and opportunities for improvement.

These strategies, when implemented holistically and in coordination with one another, can contribute to accelerating women's economic empowerment and fostering gender equality in the workforce. 

Tambu Ndoro is a Women's Economic Empowerment Activist, Author of Franchising Bullshit: Lessons Learned in Running a Franchise Restaurant,  Founder and Executive Director of Ndoro Resources t/a as Hanga Consulting and Tamar Designs.  She is currently based in Johannesburg, South Africa.  She is also recently a member of International Association of Professional Writers and Editors (IAPWE).  She can be reached at tambu.ndoro@gmail.com


1.